Early critic reviews for The Super Mario Galaxy Movie have debuted to a 45% Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer score based on 78 counts, landing in solidly Rotten territory and driving trader consensus toward modest critical reception outcomes. This sequel to 2023's box office juggernaut The Super Mario Bros. Movie (59% RT, over $1.3 billion worldwide) earns praise for Illumination's jaw-dropping animation, breakneck-paced action sequences, and Easter egg-laden nods to the beloved Nintendo game's cosmic worlds, but draws fire for a flimsy, overcrowded plot lacking emotional depth that caters primarily to diehard fans rather than broadening appeal. With wide theatrical release today, incoming audience scores, opening weekend tracking, and further reviews from guild critics stand to influence the final certified score, underscoring the rapid volatility in family animated film aggregator metrics.