The 2026 romantic comedy *One Night Only*, directed by Will Gluck and starring Monica Barbaro and Callum Turner, opened to mixed reviews that have anchored its Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer in the mid-to-high 40s percent range based on over 120 critic submissions. The high-concept premise—a single night when sex is legal in New York—has drawn criticism for raising more questions than it answers and for uneven world-building, while the leads’ chemistry and occasional charm have earned praise. Audience scores sit notably higher near 70 percent, reflecting stronger word-of-mouth among viewers. With a substantial review sample already in, further movement will likely come from late reviews or festival reappraisals rather than major swings, though the film’s theatrical rollout and marketing push could indirectly influence perception before scores lock.